Spd class b vs class c so sánh
|
iRV2.com RV Community - Are you about to start a new improvement on your RV or need some help with some maintenance? Do you need advice on what products to buy? Or maybe you can give others some advice? No matter where you fit in you'll find that iRV2 is a great community to join. Best of all it's totally FREE! You are currently viewing our boards as a guest so you have limited access to our community. Please take the time to register and you will gain a lot of great new features including; the ability to participate in discussions, network with other RV owners, see fewer ads, upload photographs, create an RV blog, send private messages and so much, much more! Join iRV2.com For Free - Click Here Senior Member Join Date: Feb 2018 Posts: 623 Registration matters Quote: Originally Posted by Idleup Class B / B+ or C Chassis RV�s Hello B Forum Users - Seems that lately there been a lot of interest in B+ RVs - Many manufactures who offer both B & B+ models, have seen the market moving towards B+ RV�s, since they offer the same ease of driving, yet offer many living advantages over a smaller Class B RV. While the Pencil-Pushers at RVIA - And other organizations refuse to acknowledge there is such a thing as a B+, I assure you they are alive and well and becoming a major player in the RV market. Surely, a Class B+ motorhome has a distinct difference from class C, since most C�s are built on heavy duty E350-450 van and truck chassis with a eight foot rear axle track. In my best summation, the biggest advantage of a B+ RV is; it handles better than a Class C RV and offers more livability and storage over a Class B. As the images above show - When I put my two vans nose to nose, both the B and B+ models are very similar in design. Most important, the B+ offers more livability thanks to its dedicated sleeping arrangement, walk in shower, larger living quarters, plus allows for higher water capacity. Another advantage is storage - a major disadvantage of a B is is they offer little to no space for storage, where some B+ models such as my LTV shown offers more storage than some smaller class C or A models. While I�ll be the first to admit, Class B vans have their own following and surely not every owner uses his van for camping. However, if camping is one of your uses, a B+ RV might be an option since it can be used as a daily driver for work or used as a second vehicle for entertaining, shopping or even going to a local park for the day. I happen to own both - A Midwest Sprinter 4x4 as well as a LTV B+. The Midwest conversion retains the great look of a stock fan, it still offers the convenience of being used as a camper as well. Since many B and B+ models are built on on the same chassis, they handle very similar. The only exception when it comes to chassis handling, is the Ford Transit chassis has an edge in stability over the Sprinter since it incorporates a low slung chassis design, low profile tires, and slightly wider rear axle track. While I�m certainly not insinuating anyone should dump their B for a B+, what I am saying is; if your plans include some serious camping, a class B+ RV will offer the B�s ease of driving, yet the livability of a type C RV. When it comes to Appearance - as these images show, a B+ RV looks as sharp and in some cases even better than a standard van, yet they retain a traditional van look with its slender width and low overall height. Some larger B+ RVs - Built on Sprinter and Transit �Cab and Chassis� such a Winnebago View or Tiffin Wayfarer with their tall over-head sleeper, end up entirely too tall and top heavy for these smaller van chassis. Their narrow rear axle track results in poor handling when it comes to roll moment which can be a safety hazard. Even though these RV�s such are considered Type C RV�s, they do not offer a �Real� Type C heavy duty chassis such as Ford�s hefty E 350-450 chassis, with good load capacity and a 8 foot rear axle track. The truth of the matter is - Instead of building these RVs on heavier Ford and Ram chassis, manufactures instead use lighter weight van chassis to save cost, resulting in the RV being overloaded in weight, height and width. In fact, these RVs are so close to maximum weight, if you were to add the weight of a few passengers, you would be over gross weight. This is the primary reason many B+ RVs do not offer seat belts on the rear seating, since it would push the weight over the limit. If happen to be looking for a �Real� Type C motorhome - I would recommend nothing less than a Ford or Ram truck chassis with a good diesel engine. At Hershey, I found these heavy duty Type C units selling for only $135K with a Powerstroke or Cummins engine, which is pretty much the same money as some B or B+ models. Ultimately only each owner - Will determine which chassis will work best for them. If you�re considering a new van for camping and concerned about the room, a B+ might be a good choice since it offers extra convenience when camping, plus can still be used as a second vehicle. If you happen to be Shopping - For a new B or B+ RV, be extra careful since the pricing of RV�s are now off the scale. Possible the biggest rip-off of any B+ RV made, is hands down the Airstream Atlas, this B+ RV is built on a $35K Sprinter chassis, retails for $250K + and sells for an insane price of $200,000 - yet almost identical as other B+ RV�s selling for half the price. Regards - Mike Mas As a point of information, there are many Class B + ( really Class C's , on a Mercedes Benz Sprinter platform with a one ton chassis.... The only thing is, when it comes to the Department of Motor Vehicles, you'll find out that they register a Class B+ as a Class C. There's no official Class B+.... I know they are popular for the extra space inside. If that's what you want, go ahead and get one. I hope you take it on a test drive around town and on the freeway at highway speeds to see how it feels. The amount of wind drag and tail wagging when turning corners is very real. Just be aware of it. And, if you still want it enjoy the extra space. We almost purchased one. The Class B RV I ultimately chose fits better in our driveway. Good luck. Senior Member Join Date: Jun 2011 Posts: 1,002 Thanks for the reply however I don't feel read the article - I presently own both RV's now, and I assure you there is no wondering or wagging that you mention. I recommend that perhaps you take a B+ for a ride you'll be pleasantly surprised to find out it not only drives as good as a B RV, its considerable more livable. Mike Senior Member Join Date: Aug 2014 Location: Las Vegas, NV Posts: 222 Great write up, one of the best I have seen on the B, B+, C comparison. I have a 2017 RoadTrek, CS Adventurous 4x4 XL. Take if from me my wife can fill that XL back up with more stuff than you can imagine. I have more storage space in that back of that XL then I do in my 2019 LTV FX. We enjoy both RV's and use them at different times. The 2019 LTV on the 2019 Mercedes chassis handles like a dream. I love the 7 speed transmission and the 17 MPG we get. The Steering and driving of the 2019 is a pleasure. I have been in heavy winds and open roads and have never had a problem. I think people have to test drive or better yet rent and take a week and see what works best for them. RV's are very much an extension of your home and lifestyle. Once you get one you have to outfit it the way you want and the way it will make it the most comfortable for your traveling and living. Even when it is for a weekend, week long or travel across the country. Make it the way you best enjoy life traveling. Remember there a lot of advantages of all three mentioned. Just get the one you think will work best for you. If you are not a 110% sure it will work for you, you then have to buy used to save a lot of money. That way if you are not happy you won't feel bad selling and moving to something else. My wife and I do miss our Entegra Class A at times, but feel the B+ has made the transition not so bad. If you are looking and thinking of buying and getting into the RV world, good luck. Make sure whatever you buy you are willing to work on the RV at times and have patients when its at the dealers. When you get on to the Dealers RV lot remember be ready to WALK AWAY. There are a lot of good deals out there so buyer beware and compare, compare, compare. Steve __________________ Steve & Sharon 2017 RT CS Adventures 4x4 XL for winter travel 2019 LTV Unity FX for summer travel Senior Member Join Date: Mar 2017 Location: Sarnialabad, Peoples Republik of Canuckistan Posts: 2,216 A "B+" is also known as a "Unicorn". Not to be confused with the class/type C motorhome known as the "Leprechaun", which actually does exist. __________________ 2018 (2017 Sprinter Cab Chassis) Navion24V + 2016 Wrangler JKU (sold @ ????) - 2016 Sunstar 26HE (sold @ 4600 miles) - 2002 Roadtrek C190P (sold @ 315,000kms) Senior Member Join Date: Jun 2011 Posts: 1,002 Hey guys thanks for the reply's and the kind words - I agree, each owner has their own needs which determine which RV is best for them. All models regardless of the type offer unique advantages. Thanks Mike Senior Member Thor Owners Club Join Date: Aug 2010 Location: Delaware Posts: 613 We love our B+, "unicorn" or otherwise! Forget whether the terminology is recognized by RVIA or whoever ... you won't see "diesel pusher" or "Super C" recognized as separate classes either, but there are obviously "sub-classes" within the official "class" or "type" categories, and RVers know what they are. By the way, some B+ coaches, including mine, are built on the E450 platform. That drove our choice, because we wanted the smaller size, no cab overhang like in most C's, but plenty of weight carrying and towing capacity. We got it all in our Coach House Platinum. __________________ Crabby Mike 2019 Coach House Platinum 261XL RT towing 2016 Grand Cherokee Overland Senior Member Join Date: Mar 2017 Location: Sarnialabad, Peoples Republik of Canuckistan Posts: 2,216 "diesel pusher" and "Super C" are slang terms specifically used to refer to common types of Class A motorhomes or Class C motorhomes. No one is trying to make them into a separate class unto themselves. They're generally accpeted subsets of the larger groups. People who use B+ are actually trying to convince themselves that their purchase "isn't a class C without the overhang, it's a more mature class B" by creating a new class of motorhome, wedged in between the other two, aka "unicorns". Call it whatever you want. It's a class C by industry definition. __________________ 2018 (2017 Sprinter Cab Chassis) Navion24V + 2016 Wrangler JKU (sold @ ????) - 2016 Sunstar 26HE (sold @ 4600 miles) - 2002 Roadtrek C190P (sold @ 315,000kms) Senior Member Join Date: Jun 2011 Posts: 1,002 Quote: Originally Posted by Winterbagoal "diesel pusher" and "Super C" are slang terms specifically used to refer to common types of Class A motorhomes or Class C motorhomes. No one is trying to make them into a separate class unto themselves. They're generally accpeted subsets of the larger groups. People who use B+ are actually trying to convince themselves that their purchase "isn't a class C without the overhang, it's a more mature class B" by creating a new class of motorhome, wedged in between the other two, aka "unicorns". Call it whatever you want. It's a class C by industry definition. Thanks for the reply however there certainly needs to be different classes, the RV market has changed in past years. There is a major difference between a Class B+ and class C RV. The B+ is built on a smaller lighter and more narrow Sprinter and Transit van chassis - while a true Class C is built on a heavy duty van chassis like a E350-450 or a F series or Ram truck chassis with a wider 8 ft rear track, big V10 gas or diesel Powerstoke or Cummins engines. These chassis are in a different class of the lighter Sprinter or Transit diesel engines and smaller transmissions. Therefore they are two different animals. When comparing a Class C to a Super C there is also a world of difference. A Class C is primarily built on heavy duty van or pickup chassis like a E350-450 or truck chassis, where a Super C is a totally different category using an over the road Freightliner M2 or Cascadia truck chassis with massive Allison transmissions using large Cummins or Detroit heavy engines with massive power of 1850 lbs of torque and 550 hp. There needs to be different classes to properly identify these RV's. Regards - Mike Senior Member Thor Owners Club Join Date: Aug 2010 Location: Delaware Posts: 613 Quote: Originally Posted by Winterbagoal "diesel pusher" and "Super C" are slang terms specifically used to refer to common types of Class A motorhomes or Class C motorhomes. No one is trying to make them into a separate class unto themselves. They're generally accpeted subsets of the larger groups. People who use B+ are actually trying to convince themselves that their purchase "isn't a class C without the overhang, it's a more mature class B" by creating a new class of motorhome, wedged in between the other two, aka "unicorns". Call it whatever you want. It's a class C by industry definition. I never understand why you seem to care so much what other people call their coaches. If you don't want to use the term "Class B+," don't. Those of us who want to, will. And you're quite wrong about why we (or at least I) call them that. The manufacturer of my coach calls it a B+, as do lots of other people. I'm not trying to convince myself or anyone else of anything. I didn't buy it because of what it was called, I bought it because it was what I wanted. |
